Guelph has the rare pizza scene where you can bounce between proper, sit-down Neapolitan, stone-baked “night out” pizza, and classic takeout that never misses—all in the same week and never get bored.
This list is built for real life: where to go when you want the best crust, where to order when you want maximum value, and where to sit down when you want pizza + vibes.
Roy’s Pizza
A more “hidden gem” style pick that’s earned a lot of local buzz—known for bolder flavors and that exciting, creative-pie energy. One local write-up even calls it a go-to for people craving something different.
Get it for: Your “best slice in town” hunt, creative toppings, when you want craveable.
Order: Margherita or anything with pepperoni if you’re judging a place by its fundamentals.
Buon Gusto
If you’re craving a more “Italian dinner out” pizza experience, this is the move. Their approach is simple and ingredient-forward—pizza that feels intentionally made, not just assembled.
Get it for: Date night pizza, wine + a pie, out-of-town guests.
Order: Classic toppings (pepperoni/mushroom) to really taste the dough + sauce.
Bardō (Gordon St. Guelph)
A lively, “make a night of it” spot with stone-baked pizzas—perfect when you want pizza plus the full restaurant energy (drinks, salads, shareable plates).
Get it for: Groups, birthdays, patio season, dinner-and-drinks.
Order: Whatever seasonal/specialty pie grabs you—this is where variety shines.
Piatto Pizzeria & Enotecca – Guelph
When you want a polished sit-down experience with a more classic pizzeria feel—reservations, service, and that “we’re going out” vibe—this is a strong pick.
Get it for: A nicer dinner out, celebratory meal, consistent quality.
Order: A traditional-style pie + something small to start (salad/app).
Fixed Gear Brewing Company
Pizza and beer is a perfect combo, and Fixed Gear leans into it with wood oven fired pizza in a brewery setting. Great atmosphere, especially when there’s something happening (events, live energy).
Get it for: A fun hang, beer flight + pizza, casual night out.
Order: Go a little bolder here—this is a “try something different” spot.
Victoria’s Pizza
This is classic “Guelph takeout pizza” comfort: straightforward, satisfying, and built for delivery nights. They’re explicitly geared for pickup/delivery and meal-deal style ordering.
Get it for: Movie night, feeding a group, easy reliability.
Order: A crowd-pleaser pie + wings/garlic bread.
Manhattans Pizza Bistro ● Music Club
A Guelph classic that mixes live music with a real restaurant menu—and yes, New York style thin crust pizza is part of the identity.
Get it for: Dinner + live music, a “night out” that isn’t too formal.
Order: Thin crust + something shareable while you settle in.
Pizza Trokadero
A longtime local favorite with a proudly old-school vibe. They make fresh dough daily and lean into the “simple, tasty, dependable” style that keeps people coming back.
Get it for: No-fuss takeout, nostalgia pizza, budget-friendly orders.
Order: Pepperoni/cheese to judge the fundamentals (they hold up).
Dynamite Pizza
A strong takeout option with a wide “something for everyone” approach—delivery-focused, lots of add-ons, and options like gluten-free and whole wheat.
Get it for: Mixed dietary needs, late-week convenience, big appetites.
Order: A gourmet-style pie + wings if you want the full spread.
Pizza Express (672 Woolwich St)
When you want straightforward takeout/delivery with combo options and easy ordering, Pizza Express is worth having in the rotation—especially on nights you want “fast + filling.”
Get it for: Busy nights, feeding a crew, value combos.
Order: A classic toppings combo and call it a win.
Quick “What should I pick?” guide
- Best for a proper night out: Bardō, Piatto, Manhattans
- Best takeout staples: Victoria’s, Trokadero, Dynamite, Pizza Express
- Best pizza + drinks vibe: Fixed Gear, Bardō
- Best “pizza hunter” pick: Roy’s, Buon Gusto, Bardō
